Skip to main content

Insights · November 15, 2026

The Principal Residence Exemption When a Toronto Family Owns More Than One Home

A reference for families who own a principal home plus a cottage, condominium or investment property: what qualifies, the one-designation-per-year family rule, the plus 1 formula, change-in-use elections and how a sale is reported.

This note is for families who own more than one property in or around Toronto: a home plus a cottage, condominium or investment property. Short answer: the principal residence exemption can reduce or eliminate the capital gain on a qualifying home, but for 1982 and later years a family can designate only one property for each year. A second property that is never designated does not receive the exemption.

This note assumes the properties are owned personally. How personal, joint, corporate and trust ownership affect the exemption is discussed in Holding Toronto Residential Property Personally, Jointly, in a Corporation or in a Trust. Links to the official sources are included throughout. Your lawyer and accountant should confirm how each point applies to your family.

What the CRA treats as a principal residence

The term "principal residence" is defined in section 54 of the Income Tax Act. The CRA states that a property qualifies for any year if it is a housing unit, a leasehold interest in a housing unit, or a co-operative housing share acquired only to inhabit a unit owned by that corporation; you own it alone or jointly; you, your current or former spouse or common-law partner, or any of your children lived in it at some time during the year; and you designate it as your principal residence. The CRA's list of housing units includes a house, a cottage, a condominium, an apartment, and a trailer, mobile home or houseboat.

Income Tax Folio S1-F3-C2 adds that ownership includes beneficial ownership, and that the housing unit must be "ordinarily inhabited" in the year by the taxpayer or by the taxpayer's spouse or common-law partner, former spouse or common-law partner, or child. A short period of inhabitancy in the year can be enough, unless the main reason for owning the housing unit is to gain or produce income.

The Act includes "the land subjacent to the housing unit and such portion of any immediately contiguous land as can reasonably be regarded as contributing to the use and enjoyment of the housing unit as a residence." Land above half a hectare (1.24 acres, in the CRA's public guidance) does not qualify unless the taxpayer establishes that the excess was necessary, for example because of a municipal minimum lot size. A corporation cannot claim the exemption, as discussed in the ownership note linked above.

Only one designation per year for the family

Designation is made when you sell the property or are considered to have sold it. For 1982 and later years, the CRA states: "You can only designate one home as your family's principal residence for each year."

For 1993 and later years, that family includes you; your spouse or common-law partner, unless you were separated for the entire year under a court order or written agreement; and your children, other than a child who had a spouse or common-law partner during the year or who was 18 or older. After 1981, a couple cannot designate the city home as one spouse's principal residence and the cottage as the other's for the same year. A child under 18 without a spouse or common-law partner is in the same family unit. A year used for one property cannot be used again for another.

How the exemption is calculated: the plus 1 formula

Where the exemption applies, paragraph 40(2)(b) of the Income Tax Act reduces the gain by A × (B ÷ C), as restated in the CRA folio. A is the gain otherwise determined. B is 1 plus the years after acquisition for which the property was the taxpayer's principal residence while the taxpayer was resident in Canada, if the taxpayer was resident in Canada during the year of acquisition; otherwise the extra 1 is not added. C is the number of years after acquisition the taxpayer owned the property.

The extra year is the "plus 1" rule. The CRA explains that it allows both properties to be treated as eligible "for a year when one residence is sold and another is purchased in the same year, even though only one of them may be designated as such for that year." Guide T4037, Capital Gains says you usually do not pay tax if the home was your principal residence for all years you owned it, or all years except one, you report and designate the sale, and the family designated no other property while you owned it.

The folio illustrates the arithmetic. A taxpayer bought vacant land in 2002 for $50,000, built a housing unit in 2005 for $200,000, and sold the property in 2011 for $300,000, a $50,000 gain. The property could be designated for 2005 to 2011 (seven years) but not for 2002 to 2004. The formula eliminated $50,000 × (1 + 7) ÷ 10 = $40,000, leaving $10,000. The same arithmetic applies when some years are used for another home.

After October 2, 2016, plus 1 does not apply if the taxpayer was a non-resident throughout the year of acquisition. The exemption is also unavailable on a flipped property. See Capital Gains Tax on Investment Property in Canada.

Change in use and the section 45 elections

Changing a home to a rental, or the reverse, is a tax event even if title does not change. The CRA states that you are considered to have sold the property at fair market value and immediately reacquired it. Any gain relating to years it was your principal residence may be reduced or eliminated by the exemption. Paragraph 45(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act provides for that deemed disposition.

Under subsection 45(2), when you convert a principal residence to rental use, you file a signed letter with your return for the year of the change. You cannot claim capital cost allowance while the election is in effect, and net rental income must still be reported. You may designate the property as your principal residence for up to four years even if you do not live in it, provided you designate no other property for those years and you are resident or deemed resident in Canada. The four-year limit can be extended in certain employment-relocation cases.

Under subsection 45(3), when you convert a rental to a principal residence, a signed letter, usually filed with the return for the year of the actual sale or within 90 days after the CRA asks, postpones the deemed disposition until that sale. The election cannot be made if you, your spouse or common-law partner, or a trust under which either of you is a beneficiary claimed capital cost allowance on the property after 1984 and on or before the change in use. You may then designate the property for up to four years before you occupy it.

Reporting the sale: Schedule 3 and Form T2091(IND)

If you sold or were considered to have sold a property that was at any time your principal residence, you must report the sale on Schedule 3, Capital Gains or Losses and complete Form T2091(IND), Designation of a Property as a Principal Residence by an Individual (Other Than a Personal Trust). If it was your principal residence for every year you owned it, or every year except one, you complete only the first page of the form.

For 2016 and later years, the CRA allows the exemption only if the sale and designation are reported. A late designation may be accepted, but a penalty may apply. A separate Form T2091(IND) is required for each such property sold in the same year. If the owner has died, the legal representative uses Schedule 3 and Form T1255 on the final return. See Holding Ontario Real Estate Through an Estate.

Selling a second property that was never designated

Designation happens when a property is sold or is considered sold. Years used on one sale cannot later be used for another property.

If a second property is sold and no years are designated for it, the exemption does not reduce the gain. The CRA states that if your home was not your principal residence for every year you owned it, "you have to report the part of the capital gain on the property that relates to the years you did not designate the property as your principal residence." Where no years can be designated, the full gain is generally a capital gain. See Capital Gains Tax on Investment Property in Canada.

The family's accountant should model which years to attach to which property before either is listed. A residence is personal-use property, and a loss on its sale cannot be claimed.

How I work with your advisers

My role is on the real estate side: timing a sale or a change of use so that the designation and any elections your advisers recommend can be carried through cleanly. I work alongside each client's lawyer and accountant, who advise on the tax. For a confidential conversation, I can be reached through the contact page.

Frequently asked questions

Can a family designate both a Toronto home and a cottage as principal residences for the same year?

No. For 1982 and later years, only one property per family unit can be designated as a principal residence for each year. The family unit includes you, your spouse or common-law partner (unless you were separated for the entire year under a court order or written agreement), and your children other than a child who had a spouse or common-law partner during the year or who was 18 or older during the year.

What is the plus 1 rule?

The exemption formula adds one extra year to the number of years a property is designated, if you were resident in Canada during the year you acquired it. That extra year lets both a home you sell and a home you buy in the same year be treated as eligible for the exemption for that overlapping year, even though only one property may be designated for the year. It is also why a home that was your principal residence for all the years you owned it, or for all years except one, is usually fully exempt if the other conditions are met.

What happens if I convert my principal residence into a rental?

You are generally considered to have sold the property at fair market value and immediately reacquired it. Any gain that relates to the years it was your principal residence may be reduced or eliminated by the exemption. You can instead elect under subsection 45(2) not to be considered to have started the rental use, by filing a signed letter with your return for the year of the change. You cannot claim capital cost allowance while that election is in effect. You may then designate the property as your principal residence for up to four further years, subject to the conditions in the CRA's guidance.

Do I have to report the sale of my principal residence even if the entire gain is exempt?

Yes. For 2016 and later tax years, the CRA allows the exemption only if you report the sale and designate the property on Schedule 3 and Form T2091(IND). If the property was your principal residence for every year you owned it, or for every year except one, you complete only the first page of Form T2091(IND).

Discuss your objectives.

Daniel Kim & Associates provides direct, informed advisory on acquisitions, dispositions and portfolio strategy.

Request a Conversation