A reference for parents considering a gift, a below-value sale or a shared title arrangement with an adult child: the fair market value rule, the principal residence exemption, Ontario and Toronto land transfer tax, and how a lifetime transfer interacts with the estate.
This note is for parents considering moving a Toronto home, condominium or investment property to an adult child during their lifetime, by gift, by a sale below market value, or by adding the child to title. Short answer: for income tax purposes, a gift or below-value transfer to a child is generally treated as a sale at fair market value, so any accrued gain is reported by the parent in the year of the transfer. Land transfer tax depends on what the child actually gives, including any mortgage assumed. Adding a child to title raises a separate question of beneficial ownership, which should be settled with counsel before anything is registered. Your lawyer and accountant should confirm how each point applies to your family.
The starting point: fair market value
A parent and child are related persons, and the CRA's Guide T4037, Capital Gains states that related persons, including individuals connected by blood relationship or adoption, "are not considered to deal with each other at arm's length."
The same guide states: "If you give capital property as a gift, you are considered to have sold it at its FMV at the time you give the gift." The rule comes from paragraph 69(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act. Under paragraph 69(1)(c), a person who acquires property by gift is deemed to acquire it at its fair market value. The parent reports the gain for the year of the gift, although no money changes hands, and the child starts with a cost equal to the value at that date. How that gain is taxed is discussed in Capital Gains Tax on Investment Property in Canada.
Selling to a child below market value
Some families consider a reduced-price sale instead of a gift. T4037 states: "If you sell property to someone with whom you do not deal at arm's length and the selling price is less than its FMV, your selling price is considered to be the FMV."
The parent is taxed as if the full value had been received. The rule deeming a fair market value cost to the recipient is written for property acquired by gift, bequest or inheritance, so how the child's cost is determined on a reduced-price sale, and whether part of the gain could be taxed twice, is a question for the family's accountant before a price is agreed.
The principal residence exemption
If the property has been the parent's home, the deemed sale may be sheltered in whole or in part. The CRA explains that when you sell your home or are considered to have sold it, you usually do not pay tax on the gain if the property was solely your principal residence for every year you owned it. The transfer must still be reported on Schedule 3 and Form T2091(IND), Designation of a Property as a Principal Residence by an Individual (Other Than a Personal Trust). For 2016 and later years, the CRA allows the exemption only if the disposition and designation are reported.
A family can designate only one home for each year, but the parent's family unit does not include a child who was 18 or older, or had a spouse or common-law partner, during the year. Once an adult child owns and lives in a home, that child's designation is separate from the parents'.
Ontario land transfer tax on a family transfer
Ontario's Land Transfer Tax Act charges tax on the "value of the consideration," which includes the price paid and the value of any liability the transferee assumes. The Ministry of Finance's guidance on transactions for nominal consideration states that "The Act does not exempt gifts of land from land transfer tax." Where no consideration passes in any form, the computed tax is nil.
A mortgage changes the result. The same guidance states that consideration includes the assumption of any liabilities, and that if there is an outstanding encumbrance, tax will be payable on the amount outstanding at registration, regardless of the relationship between the parties, except for certain transfers between spouses. The Ministry's frequently asked questions address the parent-to-child case directly: where a parent transfers a half interest to a child and there is a mortgage, the value of the consideration includes one half of the principal balance and accrued interest still owing, plus any other consideration given.
The regulations under the Act include exemptions for certain transfers between spouses and certain conveyances of family farms or family businesses. Neither is a general exemption for a transfer from a parent to an adult child.
Toronto municipal land transfer tax
For property in the city, the City of Toronto applies its Municipal Land Transfer Tax in addition to the provincial tax, with rates set by value of consideration. Its guidance for lawyers describes how to obtain verification that no municipal tax is payable, which includes evidence that the Ministry of Finance has endorsed documents showing no provincial tax is payable. Rates for higher-value homes are covered in Toronto Land Transfer Tax on Luxury Homes: Worked Examples.
Adding a child to title: legal and beneficial ownership
Adding an adult child as a joint tenant is often proposed as a way to pass a home outside the estate. Ontario's land transfer tax guidance defines joint tenancy as ownership in which each owner holds an undivided interest in the whole "and attached to which is the right of survivorship."
Registered title does not always settle beneficial ownership. In Pecore v. Pecore, 2007 SCC 17, a case about joint bank and investment accounts, the Supreme Court of Canada held that "The presumption of resulting trust is the general rule for gratuitous transfers and the onus is placed on the transferee to demonstrate that a gift was intended," and that the presumption of advancement does not apply to independent adult children. Whether and how that reasoning applies to a particular title transfer, and what documentation should record the parent's intention, are questions for counsel.
It matters for tax as well. Paragraph 69(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act refers separately to "a disposition that does not result in a change in the beneficial ownership of the property", and Ontario's land transfer tax applies to unregistered dispositions of a beneficial interest in land. Counsel and the accountant should agree on the intended beneficial ownership before registration.
Income from the property after the transfer
If the property earns rent after the transfer, the attribution rules are relevant. The rule in subsection 74.1(2) that attributes to the transferor the income from property transferred to a related person applies to a person under 18. It does not apply for a taxation year by the end of which that person has turned 18. A separate rule in subsection 56(4.1) can attribute income to a lender where a loan is made to a non-arm's length individual, including an adult child, and one of the main reasons for the loan was to reduce or avoid tax by shifting income from the property.
A simple illustration
The following figures are hypothetical and ignore selling costs. A parent bought a Toronto condominium as a rental for $600,000 and never lived in it. It is now worth $1,000,000, and there is no mortgage.
If the parent gives the condominium to an adult child, the parent is deemed to have received $1,000,000 and reports a $400,000 capital gain. The child's cost is $1,000,000. Because nothing is paid and no mortgage is assumed, the value of the consideration for land transfer tax is nil.
If the parent instead sells it to the child for $600,000, the parent is still deemed to have received $1,000,000 and reports the same $400,000 gain. The value of the consideration is now $600,000. Applying the provincial rates in section 2 of the Land Transfer Tax Act, Ontario tax would be $8,475. Toronto's published municipal rates for this value are the same, so municipal tax would also be $8,475, before any refund or rebate for which the child may qualify.
Lifetime transfers and the estate
A lifetime transfer changes when the gain is taxed, not whether it is. Under subsection 70(5), a taxpayer is deemed to dispose of each capital property at fair market value immediately before death. A property given away during life is no longer owned at death, so the gain accrued to the date of the gift is reported on the parent's return for that year instead.
For Ontario Estate Administration Tax, the province's guidance lists "assets where there is joint ownership that automatically become assets of the other owner(s)" among the assets not included in the estate's value, and lists "all property of the deceased that was held in another person's name" among the assets that are included. Which applies depends on the beneficial ownership question above. See Holding Ontario Real Estate Through an Estate, and for a comparison of personal, joint, corporate and trust ownership, Holding Toronto Residential Property Personally, Jointly, in a Corporation or in a Trust: What Changes.
How I work with your advisers
My role is on the real estate side: providing a considered view of market value as at the transfer date, which your advisers may wish to support with a formal appraisal, and coordinating timing so that the structure your lawyer and accountant recommend can be carried through cleanly. I work alongside each client's counsel and accountants, who advise on the tax and legal questions. For a confidential conversation, I can be reached through the contact page.
Frequently asked questions
If I give my Toronto condominium to my adult child, do I pay tax even though I receive nothing?
Generally, yes, if there is an accrued gain. The CRA treats a gift of capital property as a sale at fair market value at the time of the gift, and you include any taxable capital gain on your return for that year. If the property was your principal residence for every year you owned it, the principal residence exemption may eliminate the gain, but the disposition must still be reported on Schedule 3 and Form T2091(IND).
Can I sell the property to my child for a lower price to reduce the tax?
Not for the parent's side of the transaction. When you sell to someone with whom you do not deal at arm's length for less than fair market value, the CRA considers your selling price to be the fair market value. How the child's cost is determined in that case is a question for your accountant.
Is there Ontario land transfer tax when a parent gifts a property to a child?
Ontario does not exempt gifts of land as such, but if no consideration of any kind passes, the tax is calculated on a nil value and is nil. If the child assumes a mortgage, tax is payable on the amount outstanding at registration, and on a transfer of a half interest the consideration includes half of the mortgage balance and accrued interest. In Toronto, the municipal tax is charged in addition to the provincial tax.
Does adding my adult child to title as a joint tenant keep the property out of my estate?
Not necessarily. Ontario's estate administration tax guidance excludes jointly owned assets that automatically pass to the surviving owner, but includes property of the deceased held in another person's name. In a case about joint accounts, the Supreme Court of Canada held that a gratuitous transfer to an independent adult child is presumed to be held in trust for the parent unless the child shows that a gift was intended. Your lawyer should advise on documenting your intention before the transfer.